European strategic culture: specifics of formation and prospects for development

  • I. V. Stakhurskyi National university of Kyiv­ Mohyla academy
Keywords: European Union, Common Security and Defence Policy, strategic culture, military crisis management, constructivism, norms

Abstract

The 2003 European Security Strategy calls on EU Member States to develop the European strategic culture as a precondition for an effective Common Security and Defense Policy (CSDP). The central aim of this article is to consider whether the national strategic cultures of EU Member States have converged substantially since the establishment of CSDP given rise to the unique European strategic culture that is grounded on common way of thinking on security issues. Two contrasting conclusions have been offered in the literature concerning this question.One group of scholars claims that the EU is gaining not only in capabilities and institutions, but also in cognitive homogeneity concerning security and defense issues. They argue that convergence of national strategic cultures, though slow, but did take place and consensus has already been built around shared norms and beliefs. The main features of an emerging EU strategic culture they regard multilateralism, constrained use of force for only humanitarian purpose, the need for external and internal legitimacy for peacekeeping activity, promotion of liberal values.On the other side are those who point out that Europeans still disagree over key security issues due to incompatibility of national strategic cultures. EU Member States share different perceptions of security threats, legitimate means and ends for the use of force, the role of CSDP and NATO in the European security business. Therefore, it is premature to stress on the EU’s building a strong strategic culture.The article starts by presenting the concept of strategic culture in the context of security studies. An overall assessment on how useful the concept of strategic culture could be in terms of insights to the foreign policy outlook has been drawn using the constructive approach. The process of the European strategic culture formation has been investigated thoroughly. The distinct elements of an emerging EU security culture have been identified and the main obstacles to the convergence of the national strategic cultures into the common European have been explained.It has been also highlighted in the article whether the EU has developed a strong strategic culture by applying four criteria: level of public approval for CSDP, acceptance the EU as an appropriate tool for security and defense policy, attitude towards the use of force, authorization requirement. It has been argued that since establishment of CSDP differences in national strategic cultures have narrowed, but still the EU is far from constructing a strong strategic culture. Finally, it has been made a conclusion that slow process of the European strategic culture development prevents the CSDP from being an effective mechanism for the EU crisis management.

References

Bavia, A., Drent, M., Herd, G., 2011. Characterizing the European Union’s Strategic Culture: An Analytical Framework. Journal of Common Market Studies 49 (6), 1-22 (in English).

Checkel, J., 1999. Norm, Institutions, and National Identity in Contemporary Europe. International Studies Quarterly 43 (1), 84-114 (in English).

Duffield, J., 1998. World power forsaken: political culture, international institutions, and German security policy after unification. California, Stanford University Press (in English).

Farrell, T., 2005. The Norms of War: Cultural Beliefs and Modern Conflict. Boulder, Lynne Rienner (in English).

Finnemore, M., 1996. Constructing Norms of Humanitarian Intervention. In P. Katzenstein. The Culture of National Security: Norms and Identity in World Politics. Columbia University Press (in English).

Fiott, D., 2015. The Common Security and Defence Policy: National Perspectives. The Royal Institute for International Relations (in English).

France, O., 2013. What EU citizens think about European defence? European Union Institute for Security Studies 43, 1-4. (in English).

Gariup, M., 2009. European security culture. Language, theory, policy. Farnham, Ashgate Publishing Limited (in English).

Howorth, J., 2007. Security and Defence Policy in the European Union. Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan (in English).

Johnston, A., 1995. Thinking About Strategic Culture. International Security 19 (4), 32-64 (in English).

Jones, D., 1990. Soviet Strategic Culture. In C. Jacobsen (Ed.). Strategic Power: USA and USSR. London, St. Martin’s Press (in English).

Lindley-French, J., 2002. In the shade of Locarno? Why European Defense is failing. International Affairs 78 (4), 789—811 (in English).

Longhurst, K., 2005. Old Europe, new Europe and the transatlantic security agenda. In K. Longhurst, M. Zaborowski (Ed.). London, Routledge (in English).

Longhurst, K., 2000. Strategic Culture: The Key to Understanding German Security Policy? University of Birmingham (in English).

Meyer, C., 2006. The Quest for a European Strategic Culture: Changing Norms on Security and Defence in the European Union. New York, Palgrave Macmillan (in English).

Rynning, S., 2003. The European Union: towards a strategic culture? Security Dialogue 34 (4), 479-496 (in English).

Santopinto, F., Price, M., 2013. National visions of EU defence policy. Common denominators and misunderstandings. Brussels, Centre for European Policy Studies (in English).

The German Marshall Fund, 2014. Transatlantic Trends. Access mode: http://trends.gmfus.org/files/2012/09/Trends_2014_complete.pdf (13.11.2016), (in English).

Published
2016-10-07
How to Cite
Stakhurskyi, I. V. (2016). European strategic culture: specifics of formation and prospects for development. Grani, 19(11), 46-52. https://doi.org/10.15421/1716120
Section
Article