Political, socio-demographic and economic aspects of state instability as a factor of external influence in Ukraine: a sociological perspective

  • Eduard Gugnin Zaporizhzhia Polytechnic National University
Keywords: state, state instability, external influence, demographic factors of state power instability, economic factors of state power instability, ecological factors of state power instability


The article describes the descriptive characteristics of demographic and economic factors of state weakening in their multicausal interactions, which is based on the analysis of empirical indicators of state instability of the demographic and economic sphere, proposed by the Peace Foundation and partial logical extrapolation of these indicators to the social reality of Ukraine. As a result of research the following conclusions are formulated. The analysis of the factors of weakening of the state power in Ukraine allows to carry out their conditional hierarchy which will be defined by features of a social-institutional and social-group profile of the Ukrainian society. It is stated that the weakening of state power over the past 5 years can be considered both as the root cause and as a consequence of external influence. At the same time, it was emphasized that the external influence on the functioning of state institutions, the economy, and the mass media took place at the start of Ukrainian independence. It is noted that at the level of a formal constitutional act Ukraine was declared an independent and sovereign state, in social practices one could observe an unspoken (shadow) restriction of sovereignty by the presence of infiltrated groups of influence of other states (including Russia, USA, EU countries) in parliament, bodies executive power in general and special services in particular. It is noted that their very presence, on the one hand, was a consequence of the instability of the borders of identity of the political space of Ukraine, its power and information depressurization, on the other hand - the weakness of cultural filters, which was expressed in cult attitude to actors of foreign origin.It is emphasized that these actors of external influence did not (and could not) have an interest in strengthening Ukrainian statehood, and therefore created a regime of ignorance and silence to solve a number of current problems and crises, from cultural to environmental. It is noted that at the same time, it is impossible to remove some responsibility for maintaining such a regime from ordinary citizens, who, as bearers of Soviet political culture, are accustomed to building relations with the state in the usual paternalistic format. It was stated that the consequences of covert external influence and its ignorance and tacit indulgence by the population were protest movements, which grew into the Orange Revolution of 2005 and the Revolution of Dignity of 2014.Attention is focused on the fact that the "coefficient of usefulness" of these events for Ukrainian society (except for the ruling elites) remains quite insignificant. Permanent fragmentation of state power and its delegitimization continue, crisis phenomena in the economy become more complicated and intensified, environmental problems are postponed, however, they steadily affect the creation of discontent groups. It is summarized that all this highlights the need for sociological reflection and implementation of management strategies to overcome the crisis, part of which is a multi-causal study of external influence on Ukraine, which has been the subject of analysis in this article and future publications.


Biljavsjkyj, Gh. O., Furduj, R. S., & Kostikov, I. Ju. (2004). Osnovy ekologhiji [Fundamentals of ecology]. Kyiv: Lybidj [in Ukrainian].

CAST Conflict Assessment Manual. The Fund for Peace. (2014). Retrieved from https://fragilestatesindex.org/indicators/.

Demoghrafichna kryza v Ukrajini. Problemy doslidzhennja, vytoky, skladovi, naprjamy protydiji [Demographic crisis in Ukraine. Research problems, sources, components, directions of counteraction]. (2001). Kyiv: NAN Ukrajiny, Instytut ekonomiky [in Ukrainian].

Fljashnikova, A. B. (2011). Metodologhichni ta metodychni problemy ocinky dyferenciaciji materialjnogho stanu naselennja Ukrajiny u sociologhichnomu ta statystychnomu vymirakh [Methodological and methodological problems of assessing the differentiation of the material condition of the population of Ukraine in sociological and statistical dimensions]. Ukrajinsjkyj socium – Ukrainian society, 3(38), 79–88 [in Ukrainian].

Gajduckij, A. (2017) Kak Ukraine poborot' ottok chelovecheskogo kapitala [How Ukraine can overcome the outflow of human capital]. Zerkalo nedeli. No. 37. Retrieved from http://zn.ua/macrolevel/migranomika-hhi-veka262203_.html [in Russian].

Ghirolj, M. M., Ghirolj, A. M., Khomko, V. Je., & Kovaljsjkyj, D. (2013). Stan vodoprovidnykh merezh Ukrajiny ta shljakhy zapobighannja poghirshennju jakosti pytnoji vody [The state of water supply networks of Ukraine and ways to prevent deterioration of drinking water quality]. Polymernye truby. Retrieved from: http://polypipe.info/news/238- stanvodoprovidnuhmerezhukraini [in Ukrainian].

Kharchenko, N. (2000). Porivnjannja metodologhichnykh pidkhodiv do vymirjuvannja rivnja bidnosti [Comparison of methodological approaches to measuring poverty]. Sociologhija: teorija, metody, marketyngh – Sociology: Theory, Methods, Marketing, 3, 86–99 [in Ukrainian].

Klochan, I. A. (2010). Reghionaljni aspekty narodzhuvanosti v Ukrajini [Regional aspects of birth rate in Ukraine]. Demoghrafija ta socialjna ekonomika – Demography and social economy, 1, 98–104 [in Ukrainian].

Krysinsjka, D. O. (2011) Problemy pervynnogho ta vtorynnogho zabrudnennja pytnoji vody u Pivnichnomu Prychornomor'ji [Problems of primary and secondary pollution of drinking water in the Northern Black Sea coast]. Naukovi praci. [Chornomorsjkogho derzhavnogho universytetu imeni Petra Moghyly]. Ser. Tekhnoghenna bezpeka, 169 (157), 98–103 [in Ukrainian].

Kryvova, O., Kovalenko, O., & Kurylo, I. (2009). Reghionaljni osoblyvosti narodzhuvanosti v Ukrajini ta jiji determinanty (dosvid analizu baghatomirnymy statystychnymy metodamy) [Regional features of birth rate in Ukraine and its determinants (experience of analysis by multidimensional statistical methods)]. Reghionaljni aspekty rozvytku produktyvnykh syl Ukrajiny, 14, 44–47 [in Ukrainian].

Kurylo, I. O. (2014). Demoghrafichni procesy ta struktury v Ukrajini: suchasni reghionaljni osoblyvosti [Demographic processes and structures in Ukraine: modern regional features]. Aktualjni problemy rozvytku ekonomiky reghionu – The actual problems of regional economy development, 2 (10), 138–145 [in Ukrainian].

Kyfjak, V. I., Vasylychuk M. I., & Shkribljak D. Ju. (2019). Problema trudovoji mighraciji v Ukrajini ta shljakhy vyrishennja [The problem of labor migration in Ukraine and ways to solve it]. Prychornomorski ekonomichni studii – Black sea economic studies, 37, 169–170 [in Ukrainian].

Libanova, E. (2004). Podolannja bidnosti: poghljad naukovcja [Overcoming poverty: the view of a scientist]. Rynok praci ta socialjnyj zakhyst – Labor market and social protection. (pp. 26–32) [in Ukrainian].

Libanova, E. (2018). Zovnishnja trudova mighracija Ukrajinciv: masshtaby, prychyny, naslidky [External labor migration of Ukrainians: scale, causes, consequences]. Demoghrafija ta socialjna polityka – Demography and social economy, 2 (33), 11–26 [in Ukrainian].

Mighracija jak chynnyk rozvytku v Ukrajini. Doslidzhennja Mizhnarodnoji orghanizaciji z mighraciji (MOM) [Migration as a factor of development in Ukraine. Research of the International Organization for Migration (IOM)]. (2016). Predstavnyctvo v Ukrajini. Kyiv. Retrieved from http://www.iom.org.ua/sites/default/files/mom_migracia_yak_chynnyku_v_ukray ini.pdf [in Ukrainian].

Naselennja Ukrajiny – 2004. Reghionaljni aspekty demoghrafichnogho rozvytku [Population of Ukraine – 2004. Regional aspects of demographic development]. (2005). Kyiv: IDSD NAN Ukrajiny, Derzhkomstat Ukrajiny

[in Ukrainian].

Oksamytna, S., & Khmeljko, V. (2004). Socialjna ekskljuzija v Ukrajini na pochatkovij stadiji restravraciji kapitalizmu [Social exclusion in Ukraine at the initial stage of capitalism restoration]. Sociologhija: teorija, metody, marketyngh – Sociology: Theory, Methods, Marketing, 3, 66–77 [in Ukrainian].

Panov, V. V., & Panasenko, I. O. (2016). Metodologhija reinzhynirynghu na pidpryjemstvakh VKGh Ukrajiny [Reengineering methodology at the enterprises of VKG of Ukraine]. Vodopostachannja ta vodovidvedennja, 4, 12–15 [in Ukrainian].

Pogam, S. (1999). Iskljuchenie: social'naja instrumentalizacija i rezul'taty issledovanija. [Exception: social instrumentalization and research results]. Zhurnal sociologii i social'noj antropologii – The Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology, 2, 140–155 [in Russian].

Problemy dostupu miscevogho naselennja do lisovykh resursiv ta nezakonni rubky v lisakh Karpat i Zakhidnogho Polissja [Problems of access of local population to forest resources and illegal logging in the forests of the Carpathians and Western Polissya]. (2011). Ljviv: Zelenyj Khrest, Ligha-Pres [in Ukrainian].

Ramad, F. (1981). Osnovy prikladnoj jekologii: vozdejstvie cheloveka na biosferu [Fundamentals of Applied Ecology: Human Impact on the Biosphere]. Leningrad: Gidrometeoizdat [in Russian].

Rozja, Ju. Ju. (2013). Smertnistj v Ukrajini: teoretyko-sociologhichnyj aspekt [Mortality in Ukraine: theoretical and sociological aspect]. Candidate’s abstract. Zaporizhzhja: Klasychnyj pryvat. un-t [in Ukrainian].

Shevchuk, P. Je. (2007). Suchasni zrushennja u reghionaljnij dyferenciaciji smertnosti ta tryvalosti zhyttja v Ukrajini [Modern shifts in the regional differentiation of mortality and life expectancy in Ukraine]. Demoghrafija ta socialjna ekonomika – Demography and social economy, 2, 24–37 [in Ukrainian].

Tolstykh, N. V. (2003) Socialjne vykljuchennja v suchasnij Ukrajini: sproba ocinky. [Social exclusion in modern Ukraine: an attempt to assess]. Ukrajinsjkyj socium – Ukrainian society, 1 (2), 81–85 [in Ukrainian].

Tyndyk, N. P. (2006). Svitovyj mighracijnyj proces: teorija, praktyka, derzhavne reghuljuvannja [World migration process: theory, practice, state regulation]. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].

Vymirjuvannja jakosti zhyttja v Ukrajini. Analitychna dopovidj [Measuring the quality of life in Ukraine. Analytical report]. (2013). Kyiv. Retrieved from http://www.idss.org.ua/ monografii/UNDP_QoL_2013_ukr.pdf

[in Ukrainian].

Vymusheni pereselenci ta pryjmajuchi ghromady: uroky dlja efektyvnoji suspiljnoji adaptaciji j integhraciji: naukova dopovidj [Internally Displaced Persons and Host Communities: Lessons for Effective Social Adaptation and Integration: A Scientific Report]. (2016). Kyiv: NAN Ukrajiny, DU «In-t ekon. ta proghnozuv. NAN Ukrajiny»

[in Ukrainian].

How to Cite
Gugnin, E. (2020). Political, socio-demographic and economic aspects of state instability as a factor of external influence in Ukraine: a sociological perspective. Scientific and Theoretical Almanac Grani, 23(6-7), 26-38. https://doi.org/10.15421/172062