Visualization of the image of «enemies» and «heroes» from the period of the Ukrainian Revolution of 1917–1921 in Soviet narrative films

  • A. М. Pyzhyk Taras Shevchenko Kyiv National University
Keywords: cinematography, imagology, narrative film, Soviet authority, Ukrainian SSR, Symon Petlura, Oleksandr Dovzhenko

Abstract

The Soviet authorities paid a considerable attention to the development of the cinematography. The cinema was recognized in decisions taken by congresses of the Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks), and in works of party ideologists, as an important tool of influence for masses. The Soviet movies carried an ideological burden - they played a role of party agitators and imposed images of the «heroes» and «enemies» on viewers. The purpose of the article is to examine how the image of «heroes» and «enemies» from the period of revolution was developed in the Soviet narrative films of 1920th-1950th. The analysis of papers and books on the history of Ukrainian cinematography proves that the problem was not properly investigated by researchers. The article, by applying approaches of the historical imagology, explores the process of how the images of «heroes» and «enemies» in the Ukrainian Soviet films were created and popularized. One of the main topics of the Soviet cinema was the history of the revolutionary events, which were presented according to ideological requirements of the authorities. Films of various genres reflected the struggle of the Bolsheviks for the establishment and maintenance of the power in 1917-1921. They formed a stable perception of the images of the «enemy» and «hero» of the revolution. For example, in the 1920th, «enemies» were depicted as insidious, corrupt, ruthless and at the same time – as miserable and comic in such films as «Ostap Bandura» (1924), «Piłsudski bought Petlura» (1926), «Two days» (1927), «Zvenyhora» (1927), «Arsenal» (1929), «Night driver» (1929). Instead, the «heroes» were simple, accessible, open. In the 1930th, when the building of a totalitarian system in the USSR had been completed, the images obtained some additional features. Thus, in Oleksandr Dovzhenko’s films «Shchors» (1939) and Ihor Savchenko’s «The Riders» (1939), «enemies» became increasingly hidden, insincere and hypocritical, and «heroes» were purposeful, straightforward and confident of victory. In the films made during and after the German-Soviet war «enemies» were depicted contemptuously. They were uncertain and weak-willed. While the revolutionary «heroes», on the contrary, were calm, conscious and acting in accordance with the plan. Such images were embodied in the films «Alexander Parkhomenko» (1942) and «The Truth» (1957). Soviet films impose images of the «enemies» which weak, anti-popular, dependent on external support and struggling against Soviet power in vain. Symon Petlura was the main personified «enemy» in the Soviet films. The images of the «heroes» were the embodiment of the glorious revolutionary past, the force of the Soviet power, the victorious progress of the communist revolution. The Soviet cinematography throughout its existence opposed the images of the «enemy» and «hero» and presented the inevitable defeat for one and the victory for the other. Nowadays, the creation of new visual images of «heroes» and «enemies» of the Ukrainian Revolution of 1917–1921 remains an urgent task for Ukraine.

References

1. Avenarius, H.A. (1936). Problema khudozhnoho obrazu u filmakh O. P. Dovzhenka [The problem of artistic image in the films of O. P. Dovzhenko]. Kino, 4, 18-23 [in Ukrainian].
2. Bazhan, M. (1927). Lehendy ta istoriia [Legends and History]. Kino, 2, 21-22 [in Ukrainian].
3. Bezklubenko, S.D. (2001). Ukrainske kino: nacherk istorii [Ukrainian Cinema: The Review of History]. KNUKiM, Kyiv
[in Ukrainian].
4. Berest, B. (1962). Istoriia ukrainskoho kina [The History of Ukrainian Сinema]. New York: Naukove tovarystvo im. T. Shevchenka [in Ukrainian].
5. Briukhovetska, L.I. (2013). «Zvenyhora»: ovolodinnia istorychnym chasom [«Zvenigora»: comes over the historical time]. Kinorezhyser svitovoi slavy. Kyiv: Lohos [in Ukrainian].
6. Briukhovetska, L.I. (2016). Davnia i suchasna Ukraina v kino Polshchi [Ancient and contemporary Ukraine in the films of Poland]. Kino–Teatr, 3, 15-18 [in Ukrainian].
7. Briukhovetska, L.I. (2014). Naitsikavisha istoriia v Yevropi. Ekranni versii. [The most interesting story in Europe. On-screen version]. Kyiv: Zadruha [in Ukrainian].
8. Boytsov, M.A., & Uspienskiy, F.B. (Eds.) (2010). Vlast i obraz. Ocherki potestarnoi imagologii [The Power and the Image. The Reviews on Potestary Imagology]. Saint Petersburg: Alateya [in Russian].
9. Hoseiko, L. (2005). Istoriia ukrainskoho kinematohrafu: 1896–1995 [The History of Ukrainian Cinematography: 1896–1995]. Kyiv: KINO-KOLO [in Ukrainian].
10. Hridasov, P. (1938). Obraz Lenina v kino [The image of Lenin in films]. Radianske kino, 2, 7-12 [in Ukrainian].
11. Zhukova, A.E., & Zhurov, H.V. (1959). Ukrainske radianske kinomystetstvo. 1930-1941 [The Ukrainian Soviet Cinematic Art. 1930-1941]. Kyiv: Vydavnytstvo akademii nauk URSR [in Ukrainian].
12. Savchenko, Ya., Bazhan, M., Yakubovskyi, M., Dovzhenko, O., & Khmuryi, V. (1928). Zvenyhora: zbirnyk [Zvenуgora: the collection]. Kyiv: VUFKU [in Ukrainian].
13. Illiashenko, V. (2004). Istoriia ukrainskoho kinomystetstva [The History of the Ukrainian Cinematic Art]. Kyiv: «VIK» [in Ukrainian].
14. Skrypnyk, H. (Ed.) (2016). Istoriia ukrainskoho kino [The History of the Ukrainian Cinema]. (Vols. 2). Kyiv: NAN Ukrainy; IMFE M. T. Rylskoho [in Ukrainian].
15. Levchuk, T.V., Buriak, B.S. et al. (Eds.). (1986). Istoriia ukrainskoho radianskoho kino [The History of the Ukrainian Soviet Cinema]. (Vols. 3). Kyiv: Naukova dumka [in Ukrainian].
16. Korniienko, I.S. (1959). Ukrainske radianske kinomystetstvo. 1917–1929. [The Ukrainian Soviet Cinematic Art. 1917–1929]. Kyiv: Vydavnytstvo akademii nauk URSR [in Ukrainian].
17. Kotova, S. (2015). «Obraz chuzhoho» i «obraz voroha»: «imaholohiia» v suchasnykh mizhdystsyplinarnykh humanitarnykh doslidzhenniakh [The image of «Other» and the image of «Enemy»: the «imagology» in the contemporary interdisciplinary humanities works]. Bulletin of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv. History, 4, 20-24
[in Ukrainian].
18. Kuziuk, O.M. (2010). Ukrainske radianske kino 1930-kh rokiv: suspilno-politychnyi aspect [The Ukrainian Soviet Cinema of 1930th: the social and political aspects]. Gileya, 41(11), 123-128 [in Ukrainian].
19. Yevsieiev, O.I. (Ed.). (1959). Kulturne budivnytstvo v Ukrainskii RSR. Vazhlyvishi rishennia Komunistychnoi partii i Radianskoho uriadu 1917–1959 rr. [The cultural building in Ukrainian SSR. The main decisions of Communist Party and Soviet government from 1917–1959]. (Vols. 2). Kyiv: Derzhavne vydavnytstvo politychnoi literatury URSR
[in Ukrainian].
20. Lunacharsky, A.V. (1965). Lunacharsky o kino: Stat’i. Vyskazyvaniya. Stsenarii. Dokumienty. [Lunacharsky about the Cinema: Articles. Speeches. Screenplays. Documents.]. Moscow: Iskusstvo [in Russian].
21. Sydorenko, V. et al. (Eds.) (2006). Narysy z istorii kinomystetstva Ukrainy [The Sketches from the History of Ukrainian Cinematic Art]. Kyiv: Intertekhnologiia [in Ukrainian].
22. Poltoratskyi, O. (1927). Obrazovist u kino [The Imagery in the Сinema]. Kino, 1, 12 [in Ukrainian].
23. Posokhov, S.I. (2014). Eticheskiye problemy istoricheskoy imagologii [The ethical problems of historical imagology]. Istoriohrafichni ta dzhereloznavchi problemy istorii Ukrainy. Profesiina etyka istoryka u mizhdyscyplinarnomu prostori. Dnipropetrovsk: LIRA [in Russian].
24. Prymachenko, Ya.L. (2017). Ukrainske kino 1920-h rokiv u poshukah vlasnyh tem ta smysliv [The Ukrainian Cinema of 1920th in the search of their own themes and meanings]. Ukraina Moderna: Mizhnarodnyi intelektualnyi chasopys. Retrieved from: http://uamoderna.com/md/prymachenko-ukrainian-cinema [in Ukrainian].
25. Pro tematychnyi plan. Rezoliutsiia narady pry ahitpropi TsK KP(b)U. (1928). [About the thematic plan. Resolution of the meeting at the agitprop of the Central Committee of the Communist Party (Bolshevik) of Ukraine]. Kino, 11, 16 [in Ukrainian].
26. Rosliak, R.V. (2014). Do pytannia pro ukrainizaciiu vitchyznianoi kinohaluzi (1920 – pochatok 1930-kh rokiv) [About the question of ukrainization of the domestic film industry (1920th and the beginning of 1930th )]. Studii mystetstvoznavchi, 1, 128-134 [in Ukrainian].
27. Rosliak, R.V. (2014). Tematychne planuvannia yak zasib upravlinnia ukrainskym kinematohrafom (z dosvidu 20-kh rokiv XX stolittia) [The thematic planning as a cinema management method (from the experience of 1920th)]. Visnyk Natsionalnoi akademii kerivnykh kadriv kultury i mystetstva, 2, 271-275 [in Ukrainian].
28. Setar, V. (1926). «P.K.P.» [«P.K.P. »]. Kino, 8, 15-17; 20 [in Ukrainian].
29. Trymbach, S.V. (2016). Kino, narodzhene Ukrainoiu. Albom antolohii ukrainskoho kino [The Cinema, born in Ukraine. The Album of Anthology of the Ukrainian Cinema]. Kyiv: Tekhnika [in Ukrainian].
30. Trotskiy, L.D. (1923). Tserkva, vodka i kinematograf [The Church, Vodka and Cinematograph]. Pravda, 154, July 12 [in Russian].
31. Faizulin, Ya. (n.d.) Dokumenty z arkhiviv rozkryvaiut zakadrovi taiemnytsi filmu-agitky «PKP» – «Pilsudskyi kupyv Petliuru» [The documents from the archives reveal a backstage secret of the prop film «PBP» – «Piłsudski bought Petlura»] Retrieved from http://www.memory.gov.ua/publication/dokumenti–z–arkhiviv–kgb–rozkrivayut–zakadrovi–taemnitsi–filmu–agitki–pkp–pilsudskii–kup [in Ukrainian].
32. Cherniak, Ye. (1929). «Arsenal» [«Arsenal»]. Kino, 1, 4-5 [in Ukrainian].
33. Shuhai, M. (1926). «Trypilska trahediia» [Trypillia tragedy]. Kino, 4, 11-12 [in Ukrainian].
34. VUFKU. (1928). Shcho robytyme ukrainske kino 1928-1929 roku. Oriientovanyi tematychnyi plan VUFKU [What will Ukrainian cinema perform in 1928-1929. Oriented thematic plan of the VUFKU]. Kino, 9, 17-24 [in Ukrainian].
35. Solntseva, Yu.I., & Derevianko, T.T. (Eds.) (1984). «Shchors»: Zbirnyk [«Shchors»: The Collection]. Kyiv: Mystetstvo [in Ukrainian].
36. Yanchuk, O. (2017). «My khochemo pokazaty liudiam, shcho Petliura – tse ne bandyt, yak stverdzhuvala radianska propahanda, a spravzhnii ukrainskyi lider» [We want to show people that Petlura was not an outlaw, as Soviet propaganda claimed, but a real Ukrainian leader]. Chas i podii. Molodizhne perekhrestia, 309, June 22 [in Ukrainian].
Published
2018-07-05
How to Cite
PyzhykA. М. (2018). Visualization of the image of «enemies» and «heroes» from the period of the Ukrainian Revolution of 1917–1921 in Soviet narrative films. Grani, 21(6), 28-38. https://doi.org/10.15421/171881
Section
Article